Class Separation

Victoria Bezilla, Alison Cox, Stephanie Defeo, Alyssa Dill


external image time-magazine-map2.jpg
external image Fig_4-1_color.jpg

Hazaras:

"A Persian-speaking ethnic group who live mainly in the central Afghanistan and Quetta, Pakistan"
  • Speak Farsi
  • Shi'a Muslims
  • Live in Central Afghanistan due to Pashtun expansion
  • Farmers and herders
  • Lower economic status
  • It is believed that Hazaras are descendents of Ghengis Khan and the Mongolians
  • Amir Abdur Rahman, who ruled Afghanistan 1880-1901, forced Shia Hazaras into centralized control. The Shia Hazaras resisted and launched uprisings against Rahman's army, causing Rahman to order Sunni Hazaras to fight against the Shia Hazaras.
  • Rahman also allowed Pashtuns to use Hazara land for animal pastures, causing many Hazaras to emigrate to Iran, Pakistan, Russia, etc.
  • Been more involved in government since 1979 after Soviets left Afghanistan
  • Asian or Mongol appearance

Video:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ob5b2b2rvRI

external image hazaras.jpgexternal image 1317489112-hazara-protest-in-vienna-austria_853489.jpg


Pashtuns:external image images?q=tbn:ANd9GcT8G3cP570yg20lDmqb9ceP6HCChHCMXeGca4zkpBF4GEXGKUdvzA

“A member of the predominant ethnic group of Afghanistan and parts of western Pakistan”
  • Sunni Muslims
  • Concentrated in the east and southern parts of Afghanistan, some also in Kabul
  • Reside in the northwestern province in Pakistan
  • Organized in tribes
  • Make their living off of animal husbandry (the breeding and caring for farm animals), agriculture, and some trade
  • Speak Pashtu while others speak Dari
    Dari symbols
    Dari symbols
  • Largest ethnic group in Afghanistan (and Muslim tribal group)
  • Culture is traditional and tribal (some are Taliban)
  • Society is honor and shame based
  • Low living standards, nomads
  • Located: Southeastern Afghanistan and northwestern Pakistan
  • Total of 42 Million
external image pushtun.jpg
external image pashtuns_-_pukhtoogle.jpg

Religious Roots:

1. Hazaras:
  • Mostly all Hazara's are Muslim and some belong to certain sections of Islam
  • Abdul Ali Mazari (1946-1995), is praised and respected the most by the Hazaras; nick-named "Baba Mazari"

2. Pashtuns:
  • Mostly all follow the religion Sunni Islam
  • Historians think the Pashtuns are decendents of Qais Abdur Rashid
  • Pashtuns were rumored to have many different types of religions before Qais Abdur Rashid
  • Live on Tribal lands, named Federally administered Tribal Areas, for the Pashtuns to practice religion


The Shia/Sunni Split

  • Prophet Muhammad died in 632 A.D., and Islamic peoples could not decide who his successor would be
  • Shias thought the successor should be Ali, the wife of the Prophet Muhammad's daughter
  • Sunnis thought the successor should be picked by the "elite of the community" who was "best able to lead"
  • Sunnis eventually picked the successor
  • Ali was picked as the fourth successor, and ruled after the first successors were killed
  • Ali's succession caused war to break out
  • Ali killed in 661
  • Ali's son, Hussein, ruled after Ali's death
  • Hussein fought in the war against caliphs, and was killed (along with 72 of his family members)
The Prophet Muhammad
The Prophet Muhammad


Tensions:


external image images?q=tbn:ANd9GcTlgd-fh5LyHnRyGbJyt4IA2_byyaEBTBA6nG9kqHIJ7uE5H-qn

Mazar-e-Sharif Massacre:

  • During the second sweep (after 9/11) over the country, Hazara refused to put down their weapons to the Taliban
  • 600 Taliban massacred and 1,000 kept prisoner
  • Captured Taliban found dead in containers
  • Taliban warned non-Pashtun entities they should leave the nation or be Muslim like them.
  • Mullah Omar gave Taliban permission to kill for 2 hours. Instead, the Taliban killed for 2 days
  • First day: stab, rape, slit throats, and shot Hazara.
  • Second day: If not murdered on the spot, the living were stuffed into containers to suffocate to death.
  • Up to 8,000 people were killed
  • Taliban forbade to bury the corpses for six days
external image qalacorpses21.jpg


Powerful Hazaras:

  • Hezb-e Wahdat is the primary political party among the Hazaras
  • It is a political/militant party
  • Abdul Karim Khalili is the political party’s secretary
  • Supports the interim government (emergency government set up after the collapse of a large government)
  • Helps to determine future governmental organizations
  • Mohammed Mohaqiq in charge of Hezb-e Wahdat militia
  • Four Hazara representatives under Chairman Hamid Karzai’s interim government: two of which were Mohammed Mohaqiq (Hezb-e Wahdet militia), who was a vice chair in charge of planning, and Sima Samar (physician), who was in charge of womens’ affairs.
  • Mohammed Mohaqiq currently serves in the People’s Islamic Unity Party, and ran for president in 2004. He got 11.7% of the votes, coming in third place.
Sima Samar, in charge of Womens' Affairs in Afghanistan from 2001-2003
Sima Samar, in charge of Womens' Affairs in Afghanistan from 2001-2003

Mohammed Mohaqiq
Mohammed Mohaqiq


Important Points:

1. The conflicts between Sunni and Shia have occurred since the 600s.
2. Hazaras practice Shia Islam, Pashtuns practice Sunni Islam
3. The differences between Hazaras and Pashtuns are more the root of their religion than the actual religious beliefs.

Sources:

http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2009/07/25/AR2009072502169.html
http://www.bbc.co.uk/religion/religions/islam/subdivisions/sunnishia_1.shtml
http://middleeast.about.com/b/2009/05/27/forgotten-massacre-the-hazara-of-afghanistan.htm
http://newswatch.nationalgeographic.com/2012/01/16/hazara_afghanistan_pakistan/
http://fensti.freehostia.com/Engl180/KiteRunner/Tribes.html
http://www.rawa.org/times.htm
http://www.about-afghanistan.com/pashtun-people.html
http://www.afghan-network.net/Ethnic-Groups/pashtuns.html
http://www.afghan-network.net/Ethnic-Groups/hazaras.html
http://www.hazara.net/hazara/geography/ethnic2.html
http://www.hazara.net/hazara/haz-summary.html#The Hazara Religion
http://www.npr.org/templates/story/story.php?storyId=7332087
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pashtun_people#Religion
http://info.publicintelligence.net/MCIA-AfghanCultures/Hazara.pdf
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mohammad_Mohaqiq